-->

The Upside of Anthony Rizzo

Written by Charlie Saponara on .

Last season, Anthony Rizzo, then in the Padres organization, absolutely bombarded Pacific Coast League pitching to the tune of .331/.404/.632 with 26 long balls in 413 plate appearances. However, once he reached the big leagues, the mammoth production halted. In 153 plate appearances for the Friars, Rizzo hit .141/.281/.242 with only one home run and a 30-percent strikeout rate. That poor debut may have caused some to wonder whether his Triple-A numbers were merely a product of playing home games in the homer friendly environment of Tuscon Arizona. So much for that theory. All Rizzo has done this season is continue to rake Triple-A pitching as a member of the Iowa Cubs. His .342/.405/.696 line is massive enough, but then tack on 23 home runs in only 284 plate appearances and you've got one of the most impressive lines you’ll ever see from a 22-year-old in Triple-A.

Rizzo’s production at Triple-A over the last two seasons clearly suggests that he’s ready to get a full-time shot in The Show and this time around he’ll be doing so in the friendly confines of Wrigley Field as opposed to playing home games at PETCO Park, a notorious pitcher’s park. Despite Rizzo’s impressive numbers, there is at least some concern as to how his offensive game will translate in the big leagues. His 153 plate appearances with the Padres last season is way too small of a sample size to examine, but some were quick to label him as a quad-A guy. It’s not like he struggled mightily against lefties and not righties, he just struggled overall. At least he showed that he wasn’t afraid to draw a walk (21 unintentional walks).

As with any young lefty, Rizzo could face some major adjustments against big league southpaws, as the difference in talent level between most minor league lefties and the guys in the big leagues is significant, especially in terms of LOOGYs. I wouldn’t be surprised to see his numbers wane against lefties for this season, but long-term it shouldn’t be a situation that calls for a platoon partner.

Of course, being a first baseman means that fantasy owners are expecting power. Well, Rizzo has plenty of that and you need look no further than his stats for the evidence. He only struck out in about 18 percent of his plate appearances while with Iowa, so that’s another feather in his cap, though he’ll probably see a higher K-rate in the big leagues this season.

We still don’t know exactly what type of hitter Rizzo will be. He’s still only 22 and has plenty of development left. He’s an immediate add in all formats due to his power upside, but there is risk with any young player, so the best case scenario would be to use him at UT/CI or have a good backup plan at 1B. His perceived value is so high right now that he could be a tremendous trade piece in a keeper league should you be willing to forgo a bit of the future for a chance to win now.

10 comments
TheGreatOne
TheGreatOne

Speaking of keeper leagues, would you hang onto Brandon Beachy in a 10 team keeper league?  He's at 17th round value and will have one more year (next year) at that price.  If he was guaranteed to start the year healthy I'd be more likely to consider it, but the fact that he isn't I'm thinking it's not worth it.  My pitching staff looks like this:  Lee, CJ Wilson, Sale, Peavy, Moore, Worley, Lynn, Parker.  I would think picking up a Bauer and/or Wade Miley would be worth it for this year.  Agree?

CharlieSaponara
CharlieSaponara moderator like.author.displayName 1 Like

 @TheGreatOne Bauer over Miley, but yeah, move on from Beachy if you're playing to win now.

TheGreatOne
TheGreatOne

 @CharlieSaponara 

 

We only do free agent pickups once a month, and if a guy isnt drafted, he cant be picked up until he gets called up to the majors.  That's the only reason why they are still available. 

 

I was getting ready to trade Matt Moore for Michael Bourn until Beachy went down, now I gotta make a decision.  A big part depends on if I get one of those 2 starters because with only pickups every month, it's important to have depth.  With Ellsbury coming back, I'm going to have a loaded OF with CarGo, Bautista, Pence, Choo, De Aza and only 4 spots (would be 5 but Billy Butler takes my UT spot cuz he's only a DH).  With Beltre and Lawrie at 3B and IF, Bautista takes that OF spot. 

 

Should I still go for Bourn?  I'm hurtin in SB

mark.schruender
mark.schruender moderator

 @TheGreatOne  @CharlieSaponara In terms of Beachy, based on prior TJ recoveries, I doubt he'll be back before June next year. 

 

As far as Bourn goes, I'm thinking there are a lot of steals options out there right now (Davis, Revere, Crisp) and I don't know if you need to stay locked in on him if you don't need to give up high caliber pitching.

CollegeWolf
CollegeWolf

@TheGreatOne How the heck are Bauer and Miley still available in your league?!?!

CollegeWolf
CollegeWolf

Good stuff. I'm cautiously optimistic because of how bad he was last year...

CharlieSaponara
CharlieSaponara moderator like.author.displayName 1 Like

 @CollegeWolf Way too small of a sample size and it was his first look at the big leagues. I'm not counting on him being a superstar right away, but it's hard to imagine him being THAT bad for a prolonged period of time.

CollegeWolf
CollegeWolf

@CharlieSaponara Fair enough, good point.